Lee Camp - opinions?

[The Godfather]

Are you unhappy that Paladini has said that he can go if another club comes in for him?

Personally, I don't see what the fuss is about. I think he's well over-rated by the majority of the supporters. He's a decent shot-stopper, however, I don't think he commands the area very well and his distribution, IMO, is pretty poor. If he's not willing to stay and fight for his place in the team, then I think that the club are right to let him go.

Cerny has been targeted by some of our fans but the fact is that he hasn't actually cost us any points this season. Yes, he sometimes punches the ball unnecessarily but what about that world-class save at Bristol City?

Hopefully this will spark off the QPR debate on this board! ;D

What do you think?

[weavie]

well get rid of him hes not gpood enough to wear the famous qpr keeper jersey

[Zamoraaaah]

Oct 14, 2008 15:55:49 GMT The Godfather said:

Are you unhappy that Paladini has said that he can go if another club comes in for him?

Personally, I don't see what the fuss is about. I think he's well over-rated by the majority of the supporters. He's a decent shot-stopper, however, I don't think he commands the area very well and his distribution, IMO, is pretty poor. If he's not willing to stay and fight for his place in the team, then I think that the club are right to let him go.

Cerny has been targeted by some of our fans but the fact is that he hasn't actually cost us any points this season. Yes, he sometimes punches the ball unnecessarily but what about that world-class save at Bristol City?

Hopefully this will spark off the QPR debate on this board! ;D

What do you think?

I'd love to kick off the debate but I totally agree with your points.
Camp should have got his head down in training, worked on the points the coaching staff have said are weak and played out of his skin for the reserves.

I wish him well and I hope we get a decent price for him.

[jc67]

Also agree, Camp is way over rated by many fans. Most of last season he was a liability waiting to happen. Only saving grace is as a good shot stopper. Main problem is that Cerny is a very similar keeper.
On balance I would go for Cerny every time.